Plumbing reviews in Cleveland, Ohio

Had the exact ignitor that I needed for a concord furnace. Super friendly. Super knowledgeable. The only hvac supply place that I will use moving forward..

They guys are AMAZING… Friendly, Knowledgeable, and reasonable prices… skip the big box stores… get your supplies HERE. You’ll be glad you did

I'm an old man & a broke old man to boot! But thanks to Menyhart (Jason & another gentleman there) they patiently walked me through replacing my entire bathtub plumbing system when I went to their store! As you can see, besides being broke, I am no plumber & could not afford to hire a pro to do it! At first I was intimidated by the prospect of doing this, but by the time I left their store, and with their encouragement, I felt like Peter Plumber!
Photos of my finished job! :)
Although my pride didn't want anyone to see the sloppy way I applied the glue! Other than that...NO LEAKS & all went well!
Thank you Jason! Thank you Menyhart!
Moral to this story....I wouldn't have gotten this job done if I had gone to Lowe's or Home Depot! Going to almost a century old business proved the difference! The money I might have saved by going to Lowe's or Home Depot couldn't compare to the pride & satisfaction I got from Menhart's!

These guys were nothing short of amazing. I took in my busted part, they helped me remove the stuck thermocouple, attached the new, and sent me along with instructions on what to do if it didn't work right the first time. Our heat being back on in late December is all thanks to the staff here. Much appreciated!!

Great supply shop, the guy at the counter spent time going over the problems with my furnace to diagnose the issue rather than just selling me parts. He even got out the multimeter and tested the High Limit Switch and Roller switch I brought in. He ultimately diagnosed it as a bad fan motor, but recommended I try the capacitor first for $7. Unfortunately it did need a motor, when I brought in the old motor to get the replacement he took the time to match up the old harness and got it ready for a easy replacement when I got back home. I can't say enough about how well they treat the customer (including homeowners, not just tradespeople). Thank you guys!

Have been going here for years, even with my grandmother Goldie. I usually always deal with Jason (for our toilets, furnaces, etc.) who is awesome! He wasn’t available; but Monday I had a great experience with Mark. I ended up bringing my son with me to grab a gerber toilet and some other supplies. Took care of us and noticed my son wanted candy from the machine, Mark went into his own candy stock and hooked him up. Will always go to Menyhart first for anything.

As a homeowner and not a professional tradesman, I always regret running to the nearest big box store and not simply visiting Menyhart for my plumbing needs. The times I have remembered and have gone, they always have exactly what I need and are extremely helpful with advice and suggestions. This time I had to replace my main shutoff valve due to a leak and within a minute or two I had every part needed (after running around to those other stores with no success) and passed the city inspection with no issue.

Although it’s a further drive to the store for me compared to going to a large retailer, it’s completely worth the extra miles and I will now always remember where to go first.

He was courteous, capable, competent and provided great service also came out far and have free quote

Dennis did an amazing job replacing my moms main water valve! He saved me over $400 dollars. I will definitely be using him again if we have any issues.

Waited 10 hours on a Friday & Saturday for a plumber. Nobody showed, total waste of time. First they had the wrong address down, then moved my appointment to Saturday, then a random plumber called to say my appointment got lost in the shuffle on Friday. Waited 4 hours on Saturday & again nobody showed. Absolute embarrassment, never use these guys!

Leaving another review because if you need any plumbing work done do not call anyone else. Carey Plumbing is the best. Gordon and Nick were professional and awesome to work with. I have used Carey Plumbing on multiple occasions and they never disappoint. If you want a great job done at a great value from friendly professional people do not hesitate to call them.

Carey Plumbing was very responsive and professional. They do great work and we will for sure call them in the future. Thanks Gordon and James! We’re loving our bathroom renovations :)

We had an excellent experience with Carey Plumbing! We had a drain issue in our historic home and had it investigated by a few companies prior who were not able to solve it. Carey Plumbing was professional, prompt, was able to find the issue and resolve it! We are just all around so please with the work, craftsmanship and professionalism. It was such a welcome relief to work with such a responsive and competent team!

Nick and James were really great! Communicated when they were on their way, talked me through some questions, and worked diligently. The only “negative” is that it felt a little pricey (334$ for a kitchen faucet replacement labor, for just under 2 hours of time at my home). However, this is the first time I have gotten work like this done, so I have nothing to compare to and this may be standard. Nick did everything he could to get me to that final price vs. higher, so I am grateful for that! Overall good experience and would use again as needed.

Had a number of plumbing mysteries and gremlins appear-- leaks, vent issues, and slow drains-- after moving into a house. They came out to review, quote, and within a week everything was sorted out. They were very good at communicating expectations about troubleshooting some of the issues and did a great job of minimizing cut throughs in walls and ceilings. They were thorough and did a great job!

We contacted Carey Plumbing to clear our clogged toilet and install a new faucet in our kitchen. I like that you can book an appointment online and receive a confirmation. We cannot say enough good things about Nick and Mo, They were prompt, friendly and took care of both matters efficiently. We will definitely use Carey Plumbing again. Update: A year later, we used used them to replace a utility tub faucet. I then referred them to a friend and they pumped out water in his basement and repaired his sump pump drain. They know what they are doing. They are prompt, provide excellent customer service and are reasonably priced.

I was able to book an appointment online (no phone call!!!!). They were able to schedule me quite quickly. Moe came to my home, assessed the issue, and fixed the problem. I will certainly be using Carey Plumbing for any other issues.

Mo replaced my copper pipes from a leak I had he was on time , very attentive to his work and not to mention he cleaned up behind himself I would recommend carey plumbing to anyone interested in attending to their leak issues

My bathroom pipes and sink pipes has burst due to the cold weather in December 2022. I located Carey's Plumbing in my Google search and I must say I am a VERY VERY VERY satisfied customer. Nick was assigned to do the quote and made me feel very comfortable on how the job will be performed. After I accepted the terms and conditions, Nick and Michael were assigned to complete my plumbing repairs on January 17, 2023. They were very professional, friendly, neat, trustworthy, and knowledgeable. I will be contacting Carey's Plumbing going forward if I have any plumbing issues and will request Nick and Mike to do the job!
Regards,
Quincy Jones (a satisfied customer!)

July 19, 2023
Requested Carey's Plumbing again due to the ongoing project of my kitchen repairs. I requested Nick again and as always he did a magnificent job on the plumbing for my kitchen sink repairs and added lines for plumbing purposes. Nick worked alone and he worked efficiently and diligently. This is another 5 star rating!
Regards,
Quincy (satisfied customer)

I've had Carey plumbing do two separate jobs and twice they have delivered great service at a fair price with clear and upfront communication. First I had a stack replace by Gordon who did a great job in short notice. Second time Nick and Mo came out and did an excellent job diagnosing and replacing a damaged water heater quickly and without issues. Great professional service, will continue to use Carey plumbing.

Reasonable pricing, super fast quoting, and a professional job done in just about two hours. I had a stubborn drain that I couldn’t unclog. They replaced 70 year old galvanized pipes with new drain pipes. I’m very satisfied.